Evaluate the methods and procedures. Hide References. If parametric tests were used, is there evidence that the researcher avoided violating the required assumptions for parametric tests?
Source: Adapted from Guidelines for Critique Research Reports by Beth L. Rodgers, Is it convincing that the author reviewed a sufficient amount of literature?. Let's briefly examine some basic pointers on how to perform a literature review. If you've managed to get your hands on peer-reviewed articles.
If appropriate, are subtest reliabilities given? Final Thoughts Undertaking a critique of a research article may seem challenging at first, but will help you to evaluate whether the article has relevance to your own practice and workplace.
The researchers mention that the scales were given in a variety of settings. Chris K.
This resource is primarily based on how to critique a journal article that As you read a source's literature review, you need to critically examine the material.
What type of research is this? The analysis showed there were no significant differences between male and female coaches in overall leadership behaviors.
This stems from its employees-first mantra, which plays out in a trickle-down effect. In order of importance, Southwest ranks employees first, customers second, and shareholders third.
Critical evaluation is life in elementary school essay as a systematic way of considering the truthfulness of a piece of research, the results and how relevant and applicable they are.
Were there threats to the reliability and validity of the study and were these controlled for? If an instrument was developed specifically for the study, are administration, scoring or tabulating, and interpretation procedures fully described?
- Design and Procedure 1.
How useful or applicable is the article? Conclusions These should be clearly stated and will only be valid if the study was reliable, valid and used a representative sample size. A MANOVA was also used to examine the data for differences between the three levels of coaching junior high, high school, and college with regard to leadership behavior in general.
Later in your study you may be expected to contribute new The structure of an article critique is typically the same as for an essay. REVIEW OF A JOURNAL ARTICLE: AN EXAMPLE (Unfortunately, I don't have the The author cited no clear review of literature; however, several appropriate .
If an instrument was developed specifically for the study, are the procedures involved in its development and validation described? This could present a threat to the internal validity in that participants might not have been entirely focused on completing the scale, but instead on coordinating practice, completing paperwork, etc.
- Are the suggestions for future action based on practical significance or on statistical significance only, i.
- There may also be recommendations for further research.
- This method would have given a good cross-section of gender and coaching experience for a variety of sports.
- Communication difficulties arise even when a translator is available, and non-verbal messages may be missed by the patient or even by the health professional.
It would also be helpful to be given data regarding the validity of the RLSS. At other times the barrier is harder, or even impossible to cross. With regard to coaching level, 25 0.
Conducting your search, storing and organising the literature and How to read and critique a scientific research article by Foong May Yeong. a research study. Research texts and journals refer to critiquing the literature, critical analysis, reviewing the literature, evaluation and appraisal of the literature .
Without these, it is impossible to evaluate the potential meaningfulness of this study. If a sample was selected, is the method of selecting the sample clearly described?
An additional set of questions regarding the personal history of the coach in question could have helped reduce many of these threats. The ecological generaliziability for the study is fairly high. What is are the major finding s?
- Performing your own critical analysis of an article allows you to consider its value to you and to your workplace.
- A larger sample with regard to all categories would have aided in the data analysis, particularly when looking for possible interactions between gender and coaching level.
- Importance of computer in our life essay i am working on my thesis
- There were significant differences between the three levels.
- What does the argument assume?
What is the article's background and purpose? Are the results clearly presented?
Article critique - OWLL - Massey University
Were there any obvious biases? It would have also been possible to actually go to individual schools and meet with the coaches as a group to administer surveys.
Is each result discussed in terms of the original hypothesis to which it relates? References These should be relevant to the study, be up to date, and should provide a comprehensive list of citations within the text.
Is the research important? This produced an ordinal level data set.
How to Critique a Research Article
Within the sample, 0. Graphs and tables should be clear and promote clarity of the text. Evidence of a literature review that is relevant and recent, critically appraising other works, not merely describing them Background information to the study, to orientate the reader to the problem Hypothesis or aims of the study Rationale for the study that justifies its need, i.
Don't use copy and paste try to rephrase. This will be a good practice for your final project's literature review. In the critique section, you evaluate the article using. Here is a really good example of a scholary research critique written by a student in One thing that was not discussed in this paper is the literature review.
What sort of sampling technique and size was used? Instruments 1.
There was no effect size is listed for the study. The results indicated no significant interactions. Results Results should be statistically analysed and presented in a way that the average reader of the journal will understand.
Scholarly Article Critique Student Example
While the study has merit, the methods need to be re-evaluated. Junior high coaches were significantly lower in training and instruction than either high school or college coaches. Coaches meet seasonally for clinics. When breaking down the six behaviors and examining them individually, an ANOVA was used to analyze the data.